Every cigar in this collection has earned a verified award or rating for its own size, from a respected industry publication. Most often that means a spot on Cigar Aficionado's annual Top 25 or a score of 90 or higher. It's the lowest-risk place to start if you're new to premium cigars, or shopping for someone whose taste you don't know.

You'll find the big names here, like Padrón, Arturo Fuente and Oliva, alongside boutique award-winners like Warped and Aging Room that you won't find in most local shops. Each product page names the exact award the cigar earned.

Top rated cigars collection, highly rated premium cigars

Top Rated Cigar FAQ

What makes a cigar "top rated"?

Cigar ratings come from respected industry publications that score cigars in blind tastings, judging appearance, construction, draw, burn and flavor. The best known are Cigar Aficionado and its sister newsletter, Cigar Insider, which score on a 100-point scale: 90 to 94 is considered outstanding, and 95 to 100 is a classic. Cigar Aficionado also names a Top 25 each year, with the very best earning Cigar of the Year.

Does a rating apply to every size of a cigar?

No, and it's worth knowing. Ratings are given to a specific size and release, not a whole brand. That's why we only list the exact cigar that earned the recognition, not its siblings.

What are the highest rated cigars you carry?

Are top rated cigars good for beginners?

Yes, as long as you match the strength to your experience. A high rating means the cigar is well made, not that it's mild. Newer smokers should look for mild to medium options, like the Warped Cloud Hopper No. 53 or Arturo Fuente Rosado Magnum R 44. Learn how strength works in Strength, Body & Flavor, or take our Cigar Finder Quiz.

Is a top rated cigar a good gift?

It's one of the best. A cigar with a Top 25 ranking or a 90+ score comes with built-in credibility, and the award gives you something to talk about when you hand it over.